Michigan State UniversityMSU Extension
 
Government and Public Policy Team's Land Use Services
Schindler's Land Use Page
Michigan State University > Extension > Greening Michigan Institute > Government and Public Policy Team > land use services > Schindler's Land Use Page
To find other MSU Extension people expertise. To find MSU Extension County offices. National Cooperative Extension web site: eXtension.

Land Use Questions and Answers on Subdivisions and Site Condominiums
Have a question on land use, planning, and zoning? Please email your question to the approprate land use educator for your part of the state, as shown here.  Please tell them what county you are from.

A large part of Extension's service is to respond to email questions on land use, planning, and zoning.  This page contains questions which are among the more common ones received.  The questions and answers here are compiled from those I have received/responded to, and those I have participated in discussion with on the Michigan Society of Planning discussion board.  The materials here, are written for the specifics of planning and land use law in Michigan.  Please send your comments and suggestions to me, to make these pages a better service for you.  Send to schindl9@anr.msu.edu .

 
Click to Jump to Questions on these topics:
Planning   
 
Zoning, Adoption and Amendment   Zoning, Special Use & PUD   Zoning, Open Space      
 
Zoning, Agriculture   Zoning, Other  
  • Terms of Office   
  • Residency, property ownership  
  • Conflict of Interest
  • Ethics with a possible conflict of interest
  • Appointing yourself to Planning Commission
  • Incompatible Office   
  • Voting Twice on the Same Issue 
  • No Ex parte contact
  • Why Coordinated Planning
  • Adopting Plan Under New Acts   
  • Deadline to Complete "old" plan
  • Planning Library   
  • What is in a Plan   
  • What is in a Plan Part II
  • What does a plan cost
  • Land Use and Land Cover  
  • Capital Improvement Planning   
  • Housing   
  • Zoning Amendments and Plan
  • Frequently asked questions on the Michigan Planning Enabling Act of 2008   
  • Size of Zoning Ordinance
  • Land Patents & Zoning Jurisdiction
  • Public Notices for zoning Amendments
  • Undue Influence by elected officials
  • Elected Body Acts, even if Planning Commission Recommends Denial   
  • Conditions on Zoning Amendment   
  • Amending the Zoning Map
  • Have an area with out a zoning district
  • One-to-One relationship between zoning text and zoning map.    
  • Amending Zoning, downzone   
  • Adopt Part of a Zoning Ord.
  • Petition Zoning to a vote  
  • Permit Approval based on What Zoning Says on Date Application is Received.
  • Amendment & Permit at same time
  • Conditional Rezoning 
  • Deadlines for zoning decisions.
  • Conditional Uses (compared to Special Uses & Permitted Uses)
  • Special Use Permit
  • Special Use Permit and Variance
  • Zoning Permit Issued by Mistake
  • Transfer of Development Rights (TDR)
  • Open Space Sample Zoning   
  • Open Space Administration   
  • Open Space;  Which census is used.  
  • Open Space; Adopt Open Space provisions even if not meeting requirements  
  • Open Space in Agriculture Districts   
  • Agriculture subject to zoning? READ THIS QUESTION FIRST, it trumps all those below.
  • Agriculture Buildings Subject to Zoning?
  • Exempt from Construction Code Permits
  • Changing an Existing  
  • Right to Farm Act   
  • Limiting Number of Animal Units
  • Right to Farm Act, Exotic Animals  
  • Riding Stables  
  • Definition of Agriculture  
  • Bed and Breakfast
  • Home Occupatin: employees
  • Cottage Industry  
  • Mobile Homes  
  • Signs
  • Oil & Gas Processing Plant   
  • Mining and mine reclamation
  • Setbacks
  • Waterfront Zoning
  • Keyhole development
  • Boat Docks, Boat Houses & Enclosed Docks   
  • Wetland Buffers   
  • Airport Zoning   
  • Model Airplanes (Do not try to write zoning for every possible use) 
  • Windmills, Radio Towers (Do not try to write zoning for every possible use) 
  • Zoning Administrator   Zoning Appeals   Nonconforming Issues Land Divisions Subdivisions and Site Condominiums   Other  
  • What Zoning Applies for a Particular Zoning Permit Application.
  • Taking Minutes   
  • Back-up Zoning Administrator  
  • Coordination with Construction Code
  • Enforcement; Use of Site Plans, Follow up Inspections
  • If you disagree with a decision  
  • Conflict of Interest
  • Ethics with a possible conflict of interest
  • Cross membership on Appeals Board
  • Voting Twice on the Same Issue  
  • No Ex parte contact
  • Dimensional Variances   
  • Use Variances and County/Township   
  • Effective Date of an Appeals Board Decision   
  • Variance Expiration/Temporary Variances   
  • Variances do not go away  
  • How to Appeal and Appeal .
  • Appeals are public record .
  • How it Influence an Appeal Decision  
  • What is nonconforming?
  • Must allow expansion of nonconforming uses   
  • Lots in a subdivision   
  • Replacing building destroyed by an act of God   
  •   Divisions can never be divided again   
  • Property Line Adjustment
  • Dividing a lot in a subdivision 
  • Property Line boundary alternation/correction   
  • Requiring Land Surveys   
  • Zoning, Construction Code, and Land Division Act
  •  Lot in a subdivision is too small
  • Splitting a Lot   
  • Site Condos
  • Site Condo v. Subdivision
  • Open Meeting Act 
  • Addressing, Change Road Name
  • Nuisance Ordinance, County Authority
  • County Enforcement of Township Ordinances
  • County Junk Ordinance Junk Ordinance
  • Rental Housing, county authority   

  • Dry Wells
     

    Ask a land use question in the form below and a member of the MSU Extension Land Use Team will send you a reply.  Be sure to let us know what community and county you come from - it helps us route your question to the team member best able to answer.

     

     

     


    Subdivisions and Site Condominiums

    Topic Question Answer
    Lot in a subdivision is to small. We have a parcel which is a lot in a recorded subdivision.  It is 10,000 square feet.  Our zoning ordinance requires 15,000 square feet.  Because it is in a subdivision is it automatically a legal non-conforming parcel? 
    (April 27, 2000)
         If an individual owns a lot that does not meet the district standards under the new ordinance, he has a grand fathered, nonconforming lot upon which he can make any use consistent with the new ordinance.  If, however, an individual has two contiguous nonconforming lots, they must be treated as a single lot for purposes of the zoning ordinance.  Sometimes this is done through use of the term "parcel" (as in the Court of Appeals case); other times it is simply stated in the ordinance that two lots shall be treated as one for purposes of zoning (without resorting to "parcel" vs. "lot" linguistics).  If the individual subsequently sells one of the nonconforming lots then he (as owner of one of the parcels) and subsequent purchaser (as owner of the other) are both prohibited from building on either lot.  Many ordinances take the next step and say that if the owner of an individual nonconforming lot subsequently purchases an adjacent nonconforming lot then the same merger requirement applies.  You can spin out different scenarios ad nauseam, but that is the crux of the issue.  
         The Michigan Court of Appeals (542 N.W.2d 276; 214 Mich.App. 7,  542 N.W.2d 276) ruled October 13, 1995 in Kalinoff v. Columbus Township:   
    Action was brought challenging township's failure to enforce zoning ordinance governing lot size for single family residences.  The Circuit Court, St. Clair County, James T. Corden, J., entered judgment in favor of plaintiffs, and township appealed.  The Court of Appeals, Richard Allen Griffin, J., held that ordinance governing contiguous lots in single ownership did not exempt from area requirements lots that were platted before adoption of ordinance.  
    ---Gary Taylor  
     
    Splitting a Lot How does land division work within the platted portions of a Village. Our community does not handle that many requests and we are unsure. 
    (July 1, 2002)
         The Land Division Act does not handle further divisions within existing subdivisions very well.   
         First, the Land Division process (sections 108-109b of the Land Division Act) does not apply.   
         An existing lot in a subdivision can not be further divided, or split, unless there is a local ordinance adopted that provides for a review and process to approve splitting/dividing a lot (section 263 of the act).  
         Without such a local ordinance, one is left to the process of amending the existing plat of the subdivision.  That process will require the services of a professional land surveyor and an attorney.  It is done pursuant to sections 221-229 of the act.  Some communities might try to also use an assessor's plat process (sections 201-213) but that process is not quite the function intended.   
    ---Kurt H. Schindler  
     
    Site Condos Can an individual that received permission from the Village to build two duplex structures (4 units total) on one lot then sell each unit separately as condo's? We have had inquiries. Is there a special procedure for this?  If there is, we do not have one.  
    (March 7, 2002)
         A "condo" is a form of ownership, like a deed, or lease, or renter.  
         A dwelling (single family dwelling), duplex, apartment building is a type of building--which is what a land use/zoning ordinance would regulate.  
         You cannot regulate form of ownership with zoning.  
         If the village approved a duplex, and they built a duplex, then they can sell it, rent it, lease it, or condominiumized it.  You cannot base zoning approval on if it will be rented, leased, sold or condominiumized.   
         Condominiums of land (site condos) should be regulated, if at all, in the same way the village would regulate subdivisions or land divisions--which means site condo provisions would be in the village land division/subdivision ordinance.  If no such provisions exist in such an ordinance, then there is a loophole and that type of development can occur without local regulation.  Regardless, one still can not approve/disapprove dividing property based on if it is going to be a site condo, land division, or subdivision.  They all have to get equal treatment.  
    ----Kurt H. Schindler  
     
    Site Condo v. Subdivision I realize there is a distinct advantage between getting a Site Condo approved and recorded versus getting a Subdivision platted and recorded. What other distinct differences are there between a Site Condo and a Subdivisions? What makes a site a Site Condo rather than a Subdivision? Thanks.
    (May 15, 2006)
         The largest difference between a site condo and a subdivision is the process for review, approval and recording (with the subdivision process usually taking much longer).
         I believe there is nothing one can do with a site condo that one cannot do with a subdivision, or visa-versa. There are some elements (with the condominium association) that make the site condo approach more long term for purposes of managing common properties, etc. But the same thing can be done with a subdivision association. There are some elements of property ownership (fee simple, quit-claim, etc.) where the subdivision may be preferred by some buyers. But depending on how the condominium unit is defined and set up in the master deed for the site condo most those differences can also be negated.
         With the recent amendment to the Land Division Act --requiring a county to provide an expedited coordinated preliminary plat review-- maybe the longer subdivision process will not be as large of a disadvantage when compared to site condo process. I would be interested in the private sector's perspective on how this is working --or is it too early after adoption of the Land Division Act amendment to know?
         Finally there may be local governments who have written local ordinances such that they do not apply to side condos --thus resulting in little or no local regulatory authority for a site condo. But that is becoming pretty hard to do, given court's very broad interpretation of local ordinance language which includes regulation of site condos.
         The above thoughts are generalities. Your question might be better put to an experienced real estate or development attorney.
    ----Kurt H. Schindler
    back to top
    back to index e

    Schindler's Land Use Page: Land Use Page | Education catalog | Schedule of programs| Pamphlets |for people who are not members of local boardsquestions and answers | land use links | Old Stuff | Indicia, disclaimer, etc.
    2001 Planning & Zoning Amendments | 2004 Land Use Legislation | 2006 Michigan Zoning Enabling Act | 2008 Michigan Planning Enabling Act | |Kurt Schindler
    Kurt H. Schindler, Land Use Educator, MSU Extension, Benzie County; 448 Court Place, Beulah, Michigan 49617-9518 | (231)882-0026 | SCHINDL9@anr.msu.edu | fax(231)882-9605 | Coordinates: N 44° 37' 31.2636", W -86° 5' 34.875" | Map of office location